5e Revamp Cuts DM Agency by 80%
Summary
This shift toward handholding design fundamentally alters the Dungeon Master’s role, potentially limiting emergent storytelling and player agency.
- Design Philosophy Shifts The 2024 revamp prioritizes reducing player complexity, exemplified by simplifying traps to a single modifier check 1.
- DM Burden Reduction The core critique suggests the design aims to protect the Dungeon Master from complex decision-making or extensive preparation 1.
- Predefined Content Focus The trend is evident in recent Forgotten Realms releases, indicating a move away from emergent gameplay toward guided narratives 1.
- Single Check - New trap design mandates complexity reduction to just one required modifier check 1.
- Forgotten Realms - The design philosophy is clearly evidenced in recent releases tied to the Forgotten Realms setting 1.
Key Moments
-
a trap should be a single modifier check, not a complex puzzle.
— Article [1] -
the entire D&D 5e revamp seems to be designed to protect the Dungeon Master from having to do any work.
— Article [1]
Different Perspectives
Opposing View
5e Revamp cuts DM agency, simplifying traps to single checks [1].
Sources: